City	Estimated dispatch costs without consolidation	Cost to city in proposed county/ St Paul formula	B as % of A	Cost if calculated solely by population	C as % of A	Cost if calculated by call volume (possible plan B)	D as % of A	Cost if calculated by tax base & call volume (possible plan B)	E as % of A	Cost if calculated per radio (possible plan B)	E as % of A
column	A	B		C		D		E		F
Arden Hills	72128	293648	407%	195779	271%	94127	130%	193910	269%	123936	172%
Falcon Heights	26650	93806	352%	113021	424%	35303	132%	64544	242%	68378	257%
Gem Lake	5521	20773	376%	8499	154%	7633	138%	14203	257%	4274	77%
Lauderdale	11588	42751	369%	47951	414%	18701	161%	30726	265%	N/A	N/A
Little Canada	80955	218578	270%	198193	245%	128997	159%	173788	215%	200861	248%
Maplewood	984822	941126	96%	715165	73%	761835	77%	851480	86%	1038495	105%
Mounds View	97424	186502	191%	258374	265%	171297	176%	178899	184%	158125	162%
New Brighton	168223	441505	262%	450421	268%	270684	161%	358095	213%	491469	292%
North Oaks	43672	283368	649%	78762	180%	34984	80%	159176	364%	59831	137%
North St Paul	95233	215614	226%	241985	254%	81895	86%	148755	156%	320523	337%
Roseville	327388	1045920	319%	683360	209%	487684	149%	766802	234%	730793	223%
St Anthony	4689	48355	1031%	47626	1016%	N/A	N/A	24178	516%	N/A	N/A
St Paul	7436633	4650418	63%	5818193	78%	7563263	102%	6106841	82%	5799331	78%
Shoreview	154080	694987	451%	525636	341%	187072	121%	441029	286%	346165	225%
Vadnais Heights	87075	326555	375%	265088	304%	119552	137%	223053	256%	230777	265%
White Bear Lake	527857	554923	105%	486283	92%	329904	62%	442413	84%	752161	142%
White Bear Twp	62234	304750	490%	229084	368%	70605	113%	187678	302%	38463	62%
	Average for all 17 cities		355%		292%		124%		236%		186%
	Average without St Paul		373%		305%		126%		246%		193%
Developed from information from the city of Roseville								Lowest increase from no consolidation
that appears at	Roseville Review website							Next lowest increase